GERMANS APOLOGIZE FOR 100-YEAR OLD GENOCIDE? IS TURKEY
NEXT?
25-08-2004 17:35:00 | USA | Articles and Analyses
By Harut Sassounian Publisher,
The California Courier
Ninety years after the Armenian Genocide, the Turkish
government is still trying to cover up the facts of this most
heinous crime. But for how much longer? Last week, newspapers
around the world, including the Financial Times and the Boston
Globe, reported the German government's long overdue apology for
the genocide committed against the Hereros one hundred years
ago! Back in 1904, German colonial troops ruthlessly wiped out
the majority of the 80,000 Hereros then in existence in what is
now Namibia. Successive German governments during the past 100
years, just like their Turkish counterparts for 90 years, had
refused to apologize and pay compensation to the survivors. A
few days ago, during a ceremony marking the centenary of the
Genocide of the Hereros, German Development Minister Heidemarie
Wieczorek-Zeul said in Namibia: "I am painfully aware of the
atrocities committed.... We Germans accept our historical and
moral responsibility and the guilt incurred by Germans at that
time.... So in the words of the Lord's Prayer that we share I
ask you to forgive us our trespasses." But the Hereros, just
like the Armenians, want more than just a simple acknowledgment
and an apology. Kaiere Mbuende, a Herero, and a former
government official, was quoted by Reuters as saying: "How is
Germany going to own up to the apology? There has to be a form
of redress, the injustice has to be undone." Even though Germany
is Namibia's largest aid donor and has contributed $500 million
since the country's independence in 1990, Reuters reported that
a $4 billion lawsuit has been filed on behalf of the Hereros
against Germany in a U.S. District Court. The German government
has argued that no compensation can be paid in this case because
international laws on the protection of the civilian population
did not exist in 1904. German officials have been reluctant to
issue a formal apology out of concern that this may strengthen
the demands for compensation. The Armenian Foreign Ministry and
Armenian organizations should pay close attention to
developments in this case, as it may serve as a legal precedent
for demanding compensation from Turkey for the mass murder of
Armenians as well as the confiscation of their lands and
properties. Armenians must contact the law firm that has filed
the lawsuit on behalf of the Hereros in order to learn the
specifics of the legal arguments used in that case. If adequate
funds are raised to hire experts on international law in order
to pursue Armenian claims from Turkey, it is possible that by
the 100th anniversary of the Armenian Genocide, a Turkish
Minister would lay a wreath at the Genocide Memorial in Yerevan,
apologize to the Armenian nation, and start a dialogue on the
compensation to be paid to the survivors of the Genocide. If
the remnants of a small tribe in Africa, with no lobbyists in
Washington or other foreign capitals, and no organized
communities in various countries defending their cause, can take
such a resolute stand on their Genocide after 100 years, then
surely Armenians with their international presence, political
connections and lobbying organizations can and should do no
less.
Jewish Journalist Chastises Israel and Turkey The
International Herald Tribune published on August 20 an opinion
column by prominent Jewish journalist, Jay Bushinsky, titled:
"The Armenian Genocide: Face History's Heartbreaking Truth." He
wrote: "The carnage perpetrated by the Ottoman Turks 89 years
ago, in which 1.5 million ethnic Armenians were killed or
deported, was a tragic prelude to the Nazi Holocaust." Bushinsky
said: "Hitler's determination to destroy European Jewry was
encouraged by the world's lack of interest in the Armenian
tragedy." He then mentioned Hitler's well-known question: "Who,
after all speaks today of the annihilation of the Armenians?"
Hitler's statement is inscribed "on one of the walls of the U.S.
Holocaust Memorial in Washington, and rightly so," Bushinsky
said. The Jewish journalist stated that various "interest
groups, including Jewish ones, misguided or opportunistic,"
lobbied against the passage of the congressional resolution on
the Armenian Genocide in order not to offend Turkey. Bushinsky
is indignant that when Turkish Prime Minister Recep Tayyip
Erdogan recently accused the Jewish State of terrorism, "neither
Israel nor the overseas Jewish organizations dared remind
Erdogan that leaders of nations that had committed crimes
against humanity had best refrain from preaching to others." The
Jewish writer expressed regret that Israel puts "contemporary
priorities ahead of moral obligations." He recalled: "When a
major documentary about the Armenian Genocide was due to be
screened [in Israel], the foreign ministry intervened out of
consideration for Turkish sensibilities." Bushinsky caustically
pointed out: "It is hypocritical to expect compassion and
sympathy from the peoples of the world for the lives lost in the
Holocaust when 'raison d'etat' prevents Israel and most Israelis
from commiserating with the Armenians." Bushinsky concluded his
powerful commentary with the following admonition: "Historical
truth must be faced regardless of how heartbreaking it may be.
It cannot be subordinated to the ebb and flow of modern
international relations. Anyone who visited the Armenians' grim
memorial to their martyred brothers and sisters south of Yerevn,
Armenia's capital, in the shadow of biblical Mount Ararat,
cannot but grieve with them. Israelis, Jews, Zionists and their
supporters should comfort the Armenians in their national sorrow
and the Turks should accept the photographs, documents and above
all testimony, which commemorate the Armenian Genocide, instead
of insisting that it never happened." Jay Bushinsky should be
commended for his humanity and honesty to the point of daring to
criticize his own homeland for the sake of truth and justice.
Both Israel and Turkey must realize that they will pay a heavy
moral and political price as long as they continue denying the
Armenian Genocide. Righteous individuals and organizations will
hound the leaders of these countries until they stop desecrating
the memory of the 1.5 million innocent victims of the Armenian
Genocide. To counter the Turkish e-mail campaign against
Bushinsky's column, please send a letter to the International
Herald Tribune ([email protected]) indicating your support for
this thought-provoking commentary.