MILLIONS SPENT AGAINST GENOCIDE RECOGNITION BACKFIRE ON
TURKEY
10-08-2007 15:35:00 | USA | Articles and Analyses
By Harut Sassounian
Publisher, The California Courier
In recent years, the Turkish government has spent hundreds
of millions of dollars on lobbying against the recognition of
the Armenian Genocide.
It can be safely concluded that these millions of dollars
have not only been largely wasted, but have negatively reflected
on Turkey's image as a denialist state, at a time when it is
desperately trying to present itself as an acceptable candidate
for European Union membership.
Besides lining up the pockets of unscrupulous former U.S.
politicians, now turned lobbyists, the Turks have very little to
show for their massive expenditures in trying to cover up the
genocide committed by Ottoman Turkish leaders over 90 years ago.
Interestingly, no one in Turkey seems to question why the
country's leaders are wasting such huge sums of money on
perpetuating a lie instead of spending it on improving the
health, education and welfare of millions of Turkish citizens
who live in abject poverty.
If Turkey were a true democracy and the people had a say in
how their tax dollars were spent, its leaders would be hard
pressed to explain the rationale for spending millions of
dollars to block a resolution that has already passed twice
through the House of Representatives.
Turkish lobbying efforts, besides wasting valuable funds,
have had the unintended consequence of publicizing the Armenian
Genocide worldwide. The meager attempts of Armenian
organizations for genocide recognition would not have attracted
much attention were it not for the publicity generated by
Turkish leaders and their hired guns. It is indeed difficult to
find countries whose leaders would work so hard for so long and
spent so much money in order to undermine their own interests
and give themselves a black eye in the process. The slick
Washington lobbyists, on the other hand, happily pocket the
money lavishly doled out to them in return for the promise of
curing the Turks of their genocide complex.
The most recent such lobbyists are former congressmen Bob
Livingston and Richard Gephardt who are now being ridiculed by
highly respectable U.S. publications for cashing in on the
denial of the Armenian Genocide. An article published in the
July 23 issue of the influential New Republic magazine, by
senior editor Michael Crowley, exposes both of these scoundrels
who apparently are willing to do anything for the right price.
Excerpts from this significant article were reprinted in last
Sunday's New York Times and posted on dozens of websites. This
is yet another example of how the Turkish government pays a
fortune to hired guns to lobby for its denialist agenda and ends
up shooting itself in the foot. Here is what Turkey got for the
millions of dollars it paid to Gephardt and Livingston.
Cong. Gephardt, the former Democratic minority leader in
the House of Representatives, now works at the lobbying firm of
DLA Piper which receives$100,000 a month to represent Turkey
with the aim of trying to defeat the pending congressional
resolution on the Armenian Genocide.
Crowley reported that "thus far, Gephardt's achievements
have included arranging high-level meetings for Turkish
dignitaries, among them one between members of the Turkish
parliament and House Democratic leaders James Clyburn and Rahm
Emanuel; helping Turkey's U.S. ambassador win an audience with a
skeptical Nancy Pelosi; and, finally, circulating a slim
paperback volume, titled 'An Appeal to Reason,' that denies the
existence of the Armenian genocide of 1915."
Crowley wrote that "while the Turks and Armenians have a
long historical memory, Gephardt has an exceedingly short one. A
few years ago, he was a working-class populist who cast himself
as a tribune of the underdog --including the Armenians. Back in
1998, Gephardt attended a memorial event hosted by the Armenian
National Committee of America at which, according to a
spokeswoman for the group, 'he spoke about the importance of
recognizing the genocide.' Two years later, Gephardt was one of
three House Democrats who co-signed a letter to then House
Speaker Dennis Hastert urging Hastert to schedule an immediate
vote on a genocide resolution....¦. Today, few people are doing
more than Gephardt to ensure that the genocide bill goes
nowhere."
The second scoundrel covered by Crowley is Cong.
Livingston, a Republican, who resigned from the House due to an
extra-marital affair on the eve of becoming House Speaker. He
was paid $700,000 back in 2000 to block the approval of the then
pending congressional resolution on the Armenian Genocide.
Livingston came through with the help of Speaker Dennis Hastert
and Pres. Clinton.
Crowley explained how overzealous Turkish lobbying efforts
sometimes backfire. "Not long ago, one lobbyist invited a senior
congressional aide to dinner at his suburban mansion. When he
arrived, the aide was surprised to find himself surrounded by
Turks keenly interested in his views on the genocide bill.
(This time, the hard sell backfired; the staffer indignantly
retorted that he believed a genocide had taken place, causing
the lobbyist's face to go 'ashen')."
Crowley reported that "Turkey currently maintains expensive
contracts with at least four different Washington lobbying and
p.r. firms....¦Turkey contracts the services of David Mercer, a
connected Democratic fund-raiser and protÃ(c)gÃ(c) of the late
Democratic Party chairman Ron Brown. The Turks also pay $50,000
monthly to the Glover Park Group, a powerhouse Democratic firm
stocked with connected former Clinton White House aides Joe
Lockhart and Joel Johnson, for p.r. services. That work included
advice on shaping an April full-page New York Times
advertisement, which called for a new historical commission
(which the Armenians call a sham) and urged Washington to
'support efforts to examine history, not legislate it.'"
Cong. Livingston's lobbying firm, the Livingston Group,
made almost $13 million from the Turks in the past six years.
"Back in 2000, Livingston's team personally contacted 141
different members of Congress in the five-week run-up to the
aborted vote. And on October 19, the day the vote was canceled,
Livingston met personally with Hastert to ensure its demise.
Mission accomplished," Crowley reported.
Besides Livingston and Gephardt, another contender for the
biggest hypocrite prize is former Democratic representative
Steve Solarz of New York. Crowley described Solarz as "one of
the first backers of a genocide resolution way back in 1975. By
2000, he was working with Livingston to defeat it, raking in
$400,000 for his efforts."
Crowley also criticized "Washington's Jewish-American
lobby" which he says earns "a special commendation for dubious
behavior....¦. In February, Turkey's foreign minister convened a
meeting at a Washington hotel with more than a dozen leaders of
major Jewish groups....¦. The issue 'belongs to historians and
not a resolution in Congress,' explains Anti-Defamation League
director Abe Foxman, who outright opposes the resolution. 'It
will resolve nothing.' But it's also clear that Turkey's status
as Israel's lone Muslim ally counts for a lot, too. 'I think a
lot of Israelis agree,' Foxman told me," Crowley wrote.
Besides enlisting the help of several Jewish American
groups, "the Turks have also conspicuously hired some lobbyists
with strong Jewish ties. Their payroll includes a Washington
firm called Southfive Strategies, which bills itself as 'a
Washington D.C. consulting boutique with access to the White
House, congressional leadership, and influential media
organizations.' South five is run by Jason Epstein, a former
Capitol Hill lobbyist for B'nai B'rith, and Lenny Ben-David, an
Israeli-born former deputy chief of mission at Israel's
Washington embassy and a longtime AIPAC staffer whose previous
firm, Israel Consult, also worked for Turkey," Crowley revealed.
When Congress returns from its summer recess, we shall see
whether lobbying fueled by political prostitution for money will
prevail over the solemn quest of the Armenian-American community
to reaffirm the historical facts of the genocide.